When a child is struggling, parents quickly run into a wall of titles: therapist, counselor, psychologist, psychiatrist, behavior analyst. Choosing between a child psychologist and a psychiatrist, or deciding whether a therapist is enough, is confusing because the names sound alike and the roles overlap. This guide explains what each one does and which to call first.
The short answer
| Professional | Training | Therapy | Formal testing | Prescribes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Therapist or counselor | Master’s degree and state license | Yes | Limited | No |
| Psychologist | Doctoral degree and state license | Yes | Yes | Generally no |
| Psychiatrist | Medical doctor with a psychiatry specialty | Sometimes | No | Yes |
| Behavior analyst | Graduate degree and board certification | ABA | Behavioral assessment | No |
Therapists and counselors
These are master’s level clinicians licensed by the state. In Florida the most common licenses are:
- LMHC, licensed mental health counselor
- LCSW, licensed clinical social worker
- LMFT, licensed marriage and family therapist
They provide psychotherapy, also called talk therapy. The American Psychological Association describes psychotherapy as a collaborative treatment based on the relationship between a person and a trained professional, grounded in dialogue, that helps people learn new ways of handling problems.
Good first step for: worries and fears, sadness, anger, behavior problems at home or school, grief, family conflict, adjusting to a move or a divorce.
Psychologists
Psychologists hold a doctoral degree (PhD or PsyD). They provide therapy and are also trained in formal psychological testing: standardized measures of intelligence, learning, attention, development, emotions and behavior.
Right professional for: questions that need testing, such as autism, ADHD, learning disorders or giftedness, and complex cases where the diagnosis is unclear.
Psychiatrists
A psychiatrist is a medical doctor. According to the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, a child and adolescent psychiatrist is a physician who specializes in diagnosing and treating disorders of thinking, feeling and behavior in children, adolescents and their families, with years of additional training after medical school.
Because they are physicians, psychiatrists can consider medical causes, order laboratory tests and prescribe medication.
Right professional for: severe or persistent symptoms, safety concerns, cases where therapy has not been enough, and any time medication is being considered.
Other medical professionals also prescribe for children, including pediatricians and psychiatric nurse practitioners.
Behavior analysts
A board certified behavior analyst (BCBA) designs and supervises Applied Behavior Analysis programs. This is a different profession from the three above, described by the Behavior Analyst Certification Board. Behavior analysts are involved most often when a child has autism or significant behavioral needs. Our guide to ABA therapy in Miami explains how that works.
Which one first
- “My child is anxious, sad or acting out.” Start with a therapist or counselor.
- “I think it might be autism, ADHD or a learning problem.” Start with an assessment by a psychologist. See how to get an autism evaluation in Miami.
- “Therapy is not enough” or “we are wondering about medication.” Ask for a psychiatric evaluation.
- “My child has an autism diagnosis and needs skills and behavior support.” A behavior analyst.
- “I do not know.” Start with your pediatrician or with a clinic that offers an initial assessment and can point you to the right professional.
- “It is an emergency.” Call 911, or call or text 988 for a mental health crisis.
These professionals work together more often than they replace one another. A child may see a therapist weekly, a psychiatrist every few weeks for medication, and have had testing with a psychologist once.
What matters more than the title
- A current license. In Florida you can verify licenses through the state’s online license lookup.
- Experience with children of your child’s age. Working with a five-year-old is not the same as working with a fifteen-year-old.
- Fit. Your child should feel safe, and you should feel listened to. It is reasonable to change if it is not working after a fair try.
- Language. Therapy works better in the language the family is most comfortable in.
- Coordination. Ask how the professional shares information with the school, the pediatrician and other providers.
One team in Miami-Dade and Broward
At Nova Community Services the professionals described here work as one team: licensed psychologists and behavior analysts carry out the assessment, licensed clinicians provide counseling, individual therapy and group therapy, a psychiatrist conducts the psychiatric evaluation, and behavior analysts deliver ABA. A case manager can help connect the pieces with school and community supports.
You do not need to know in advance which one your child needs. That is what the first visit is for. We see families in Palmetto Bay and Sunrise, in English and Spanish, and verify your insurance before the first appointment. Contact us to get started.